[158]
Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Astaphan submitted that the improper conduct of the elections
and any breach of election law, which occurred during the conduct of the elections,
went to the heart of the democratic process. It is my view, however, that the
breach occasioned by the use of the ‘photo lists’ added little over and above what
resulted from the late opening of the polls. The evidence shows that the use of
the ‘photo lists’ occasioned the late opening of the polls. I do not think that the
totality of the circumstances occasioned breaches of electoral law so as to amount
to substantial non-compliance in the sense that the election was a sham or
travesty. This is particularly given the high percentage of the electorate that voted
in each of the contested constituency. I would therefore dismiss the grounds in
the counter-notice which urge us to find that there was substantial non-compliance
with electoral law in all circumstances of the conduct of the elections.
Did breach affect the results?
[159]
The operative statutory provision is section 32(4) of the Representation of the
People Act, and in particular, that aspect of it which states, in effect, that no
election shall be declared invalid if it appears to the court that that the election was
conducted substantially in accordance with electoral law and the breach did not
affect the result. Section 32(4) is as central to the resolution of this issue, as it
was to the resolution of the issue of substantial compliance. The provision states
as follows:
“32(4) No election shall be declared invalid because of any act or
omission by the returning officer or any other person in breach of his
official duty in connection with the election or otherwise of the election
rules if it appears to the Court having jurisdiction to determine the question
that the election was so conducted as to be substantially in accordance
with the law as to elections, and that the act or omission did not affect its
result.”
The breach and the result
69
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents