doctrine of separation of powers. The constituent power is sovereign. It is the power
which creates the organs and distributes the powers.
49. The constituent power is suigeneris. It is different from legislative power.
The position of unlimited law making power is the criterion of legal sovereignty. The
constituent power is sovereign because the Constitution flows from the constituent
power.
50. In Article 329-A an exercise of judicial power is the question for
determination. In legislative processes there may be judicial process. If the
legislature has to fix the amount or lay down the principle for fixation of amount the
question will arise as to whether this is exercise of judicial power. The determination
of the amount will involve judicial procedure. When the legislature determines the
amout the fixation of amount is purely by legislative process. But in doing so the
legislature takes into account factors relevant to individual properties.
51. Every organ of the State has to ascertain facts which make the foundation of
its own decision. The executive usually collects its materials through its
departments. The judiciary acts in a field where there are two or more parties
before it and upon evidence placed before it pronounces its verdict according to
principles of natural justice. The legislature is entitled to obtain information from
any source. The legislature may call witnesses. The rule of Audi Alterm Partem is
not applicable in a legislative process. Legislation is usually general. It may
sometimes be for special reasons an individual case. There is no doubt that the
constituent power is not the same as legislative power. The distinction between
constituent power and legislative power is always to be born in mind because the
constituent power is higher in norm.
52. Judicial review in election disputes is not a compulsion. Judicial review of
decisions in election disputes may be entrusted by law to a judicial Tribunal. If it is
to a Tribunal or to the High Court the judicial review will be attracted either under
the relevant law providing for appeal to this Court or Article 136 may be attracted.
Under Article 329 (b) the contemplated law may vest the power to entertain election
petitions in the House itself which may determine the dispute by a resolution after
receiving a report from a special Committee. In such judicial review may be
eliminated without involving amendment of the Constitution. The Constitution
permits by amendment exclusion of judicial review of a matter it is necessary to give
effect to the Directive Principles of State Policy. A similar power may be available
when such exclusion is needed in the larger interest of the security of the State. In
either case the exclusion of judicial review does not mean that principles of equality
are violated. It only means that the appropriate body making the law satisfied itself
and determines conclusively that principles of equality have not been violated. That
body conclusively makes classification for the purpose of applying the principles of
equality. It is said that in this class of cases of answer to the question of the validity
of the classification rests on factors to which the court has no access and the
materials may be of highly confidential nature and the decision has to be on a
matter of political necessity. If judicial review is excluded the court is not in a
position to conclude that principles of equality have been violated.
53. Equality of status as well as equality of opportunity is a fundamental right in
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It also means equality before law and equal
protection of the laws. equality is spoken in the Preamble. There is liberty to