Case: 20-50407 Document: 00515441096 Page: 37 Date Filed: 06/04/2020 No. 20-50407 of fraudulent absentee or mail-in ballots.” Id. at 19. See also id. at 21 (noting “thousands of incidents of possible absentee ballot fraud”). 2 Numerous members of our court have likewise concluded that “mail-in ballot fraud is a significant threat”—so much so that “the potential and reality of fraud is much greater in the mail-in ballot context than with in-person voting.” Veasey v. Abbott, 830 F.3d 216, 239, 256 (5th Cir. 2016) (en banc). See also id. at 263 (“[M]ail-in voting . . . is far more vulnerable to fraud.”); id. (recognizing “the far more prevalent issue of fraudulent absentee ballots”). 3 There is no suggestion that these widely held concerns about voter fraud will not be present during the pandemic. So if there is to be expansion of mailin voting notwithstanding these findings, our Constitution and precedents remind us that it must be done by legislators, not judges. II. For nearly a century, mail-in voting has been the exception—and inperson voting the rule—in Texas. Under Texas law, only certain groups— Similarly, Justice Souter observed that mail-in voting is “less reliable” than inperson voting. See Crawford, 553 U.S. at 212 n.4 (Souter, J., dissenting) (“‘election officials routinely reject absentee ballots on suspicion of forgery’”); id. at 225 (“absentee-ballot fraud . . . is a documented problem in Indiana”). 2 Another judge in our circuit who closely studied efforts to combat voter fraud likewise acknowledged the “general agreement that voting fraud exists with respect to mail-in ballots.” Veasey v. Perry, 71 F. Supp. 3d 627, 653 (S.D. Tex. 2014). In fact, “there appears to be agreement that voter fraud actually takes place in abundance in connection with absentee balloting.” Id. at 641 (emphasis added). “[T]here was universal agreement that a much greater risk of fraud occurs in absentee balloting, where some campaign workers are known to harvest mail-in ballots through several different methods, including raiding mailboxes.” Id. at 676. Put simply: “Mail-in ballots are not secure.” Id. 3 Moreover, mail-in voting not only “has an increased incidence of fraud” but also “a lower level of public confidence”—echoing the discussion of the importance of public confidence in Crawford. Id. at 677. There is “substantial testimony” that voters are “highly distrustful of the mail-in ballot system.” Id. at 676. See, e.g., id. at 641 (citing testimony from voters who “do not trust that their vote will be properly counted if they have to vote by absentee ballot”); id. at 677 (citing testimony from voters that “expressed . . . distrust of voting by mail” because “‘mail ballots have a tendency to disappear’”). 37

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents