Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 39
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
Of course, there will always be other voters for whom, through no fault
of the state, getting to the polls is “difficult” or even “impossible.” Id. at 810.
See also id. at 810 n.8 (collecting examples). But as the Court explains, that is
a matter of personal hardship, not state action. For courts to intervene, a voter
must show that the state “has in fact precluded [voters] from voting”—that the
voter has been “prohibited from voting by the State.” Id. at 808 & n.7.
The plaintiffs in McDonald failed to make this showing. As the Court
observed, “the record is barren of any indication that the State might not, for
instance, furnish the jails with special polling booths or facilities on election
day, or provide guarded transportation to the polls themselves for certain
inmates, or entertain motions for temporary reductions in bail to allow some
inmates to get to the polls on their own.” Id. at 808 n.6. Cf. O’Brien, 414 U.S.
at 529–31 (noting failure to provide alternative measures stated in McDonald).
The record here is, if anything, even stronger for the state than in
McDonald. There is affirmative evidence here that officials are taking various
steps to ensure safety at the polls—measures familiar to anyone who has
recently visited a grocery store. According to a sworn declaration, they include:
• “training election workers on best practices for setting up polling
locations for social distancing, including determining maximum
capacity inside the voting areas,”
• “[p]roviding a table-mounted Plexiglas protective shield at each
voter check-in station,”
• “[p]roviding protective masks for all election workers,”
• “[p]roviding sanitizing wipes and hand sanitizer to each location
in sufficient quantities as to accommodate voter turnout and
equipment sanitation needs,”
• “[p]roviding social distancing floor decals to polling places to
ensure safety recommendations are practiced inside and outside
the location,”
39
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents