Case: 20-50407
Document: 00515441096
Page: 43
Date Filed: 06/04/2020
No. 20-50407
GREGG COSTA, Circuit Judge, concurring in the judgment:
This was a textbook case for Pullman abstention. See R.R. Comm’n of
Tex. v. Pullman Co., 312 U.S. 496, 501 (1941). The district court ruled just one
day before the Supreme Court of Texas was hearing argument on a mandamus
petition asking what counts as a “disability” under the mail-in ballot law. That
forthcoming interpretation of state law could have made any federal
constitutional ruling “unnecessary.” Id. at 500.
All the hallmarks for Pullman abstention were present. The definition
of disability was an “unsettled question[] of state law.” 17A CHARLES ALAN
WRIGHT & ARTHUR R. MILLER, FEDERAL PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE § 4242 (3d
ed. 2020). The answer to that question could have obviated the need for a
federal constitutional ruling. Id. There was “already pending a state court
action that [was] likely to resolve the state questions without the delay of
having to commence proceedings in state court.” Id. That parallel state case
had already reached the state’s highest court, which could provide a definitive
answer on the meaning of state law. See id. (noting that abstention is more
appropriate when there is a direct route to obtaining an answer from the state’s
highest court rather than having to “litigate[] through the entire state
hierarchy of courts”). And with the state court’s expediting its case, there
would still be time for the federal court to rule if it needed to after the state
court decision.
Plaintiffs’ main push back against all of this is to argue that Pullman
does not apply to voting rights cases. But we have applied Pullman to First
and Fourteenth Amendment challenges in the related context of election
disputes. See Moore v. Hosemann, 591 F.3d 741, 742–43, 745–46 (5th Cir.
2009) (abstaining because an “election dispute[] . . . based on an interpretation
of uncertain state law . . . should be resolved at the state level before [the Fifth
43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents