LABITA v. ITALY JUDGMENT
17
proceedings. For the offence laid down in Article 416 bis of the Criminal
Code, the periods applicable during the proceedings at first instance are one
year from the beginning of the defendant's detention until the order
committing him for trial and one year from the beginning of the trial until
his conviction at first instance. If no committal order is made or, as the case
may be, the defendant is not convicted at first instance within the relevant
period, the detention pending trial ceases to be lawful and the defendant
must be released.
89. However, paragraph 2 of Article 304 CCP provides that for certain
offences, including the one provided for in Article 416 bis of the Criminal
Code, the periods laid down in Article 303 may be extended during the
hearings, the deliberations at first instance or the appeal, if the proceedings
prove to be particularly complex. Article 304 provides that the length of
detention pending trial must not, under any circumstances, exceed
two-thirds of the maximum sentence for the offence with which the
defendant is charged or the sentence imposed by the first-instance court.
90. Paragraph 2 of Article 305 CCP provides: “During the preliminary
investigation, the public prosecutor may request an extension of a period of
detention pending trial that is about to expire where there is a serious need
for precautionary measures which, in particularly complex investigations,
make it absolutely necessary to extend the period of detention pending
trial ...” That provision goes on to provide that such an extension may be
renewed only once and that, in any event, the periods provided for in
Article 303 CCP cannot be exceeded by more than half.
91. With regard to the procedures on release, on 29 March 1996 the
Ministry of Justice informed all penal institutions of the need for
administrative services to be provided at night time, too, to ensure not only
the release of prisoners but also, among other things, the admission of
suspects who had been arrested or had voluntarily surrendered to custody
and the availability of emergency hospital treatment for prisoners.
B. Reparation for “unjust” detention
92. Article 314 CCP provides that anyone who has been acquitted in a
judgment that has become final – on the grounds that the case against him
has not been proved, he has not committed the offence, no criminal offence
has been committed or the facts alleged do not amount to an offence at law
– is entitled to equitable reparation for any period he has spent in detention
pending trial, provided that misrepresentations or fault on his part were not
contributory factors in his being detained.
93. An application for reparation must be made within eighteen months
after the judgment becomes final. The maximum award is 100,000,000
Italian lire.