Date of Delivery: February 6, 2020 Appearances: Mr. R. Clayton Q.C, Mr. A. Ramlogan S.C, Mr. G. Ramdeen, Mr. Che Dindial, Mr. D. Bayley for the Appellant Mr. R. Armour S.C, Ms. V. Gopaul, Mr. R. Nanga, Mr. M. Quamina instructed by Ms. Z. Haynes-Soo Hon for the First Respondent Mr. R. Martineau S.C, Mrs. D. Peake S.C, Mr. R. Heffes-Doon, instructed by Ms. A. Bissessar for the Second Respondent I have read the judgments of Smith JA and Rajkumar JA. I am in agreement with both and have nothing to add. ……………………………………………………… Justice of Appeal Mark Mohammed 2