8
CHIAFALO v. WASHINGTON
THOMAS, J., concurring in judgment
refuses to perform it.” §18002.3 These laws penalize electors for their faithless votes. But they do not attempt to
regulate the votes of electors through the appointment process. In fact, these laws have nothing to do with elector appointment.
The Court recognizes the distinction between these two
types of laws, i.e., laws enforcing appointment conditions
and laws that regulate electors outside of the appointment
process. See ante, at 5 (recognizing that some States
“merely impose [a] duty by law”). But it claims this is
merely a “small semantic differenc[e].” Ante, at 10, n. 6.
Far from being semantic, the difference between the power
to impose a “condition of appointment” and the power to impose restrictions on electors that have nothing to do with
appointment is fundamental to the Court’s textual argument. The Court’s entire analysis is premised on States’
purported Article II “power to appoint an elector” and “to
condition his appointment.” Ante, at 9. The Court does not,
and cannot, claim that the text of Article II provides States
power over anything other than the appointment of electors.
See ante, at 9–10.
Here, the challenged Washington law did not enforce any
appointment condition. It provided that “[a]ny elector who
votes for a person or persons not nominated by the party of
which he or she is an elector is subject to a civil penalty of
up to one thousand dollars.” Wash. Rev. Code §29A.56.340
(2016). Unlike the laws of Oklahoma, Indiana, Minnesota
and the other States discussed above, a violation of
§29A.56.340 was not predicated on violating a pledge or any
——————
3 Michigan likewise does not regulate electors through the appointment process. Under Michigan law, the failure of an already appointed
elector to resign “signifies” that the elector “consent[s] to serve and to
cast his vote for the candidates for president and vice-president appearing on the Michigan ballot of the political party which nominated him.”
Mich. Comp. Laws §168.47 (2008). Attempting to cast a vote for another
candidate “constitutes a resignation from the office of elector.” Ibid.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents