Cite as: 591 U. S. ____ (2020)
5
THOMAS, J., concurring in judgment
State Legislature v. Arizona Independent Redistricting
Comm’n, 576 U. S. 787, 829 (2015) (ROBERTS, C. J., dissenting); cf. Scialabba v. Cuellar de Osorio, 573 U. S. 41, 60
(2014) (KAGAN, J., for the Court) (“ ‘[W]ords repeated in different parts of the same statute generally have the same
meaning’ ” (quoting Law v. Siegel, 571 U. S. 415, 422
(2014)). While terms may not always have the exact same
meaning throughout the Constitution, here we are interpreting the same word (“Manner”) in two provisions that
the Court has already stated impose “paralle[l]” duties—
setting the “ ‘Manner of holding Elections’ ” and setting the
“ ‘Manner’ ” of “ ‘appoint[ing] a Number of Electors.’ ” U. S.
Term Limits, 514 U. S., at 804–805 (majority opinion).
Nothing in the Constitution’s text or history indicates that
the Court should take the strongly disfavored step of concluding that the term “Manner” has two different meanings
in these closely aligned provisions.
All the Court can point to in support of its position is a
single sentence in Ray v. Blair, 343 U. S. 214 (1952), which
suggested that a State’s power to impose a requirement
that electors pledge to vote for their party’s nominee comes
from Article II, §1, id., at 227. But this statement is simply
made in passing in response to one of the parties’ arguments. It is curiously bereft of reasoning or analysis of Article II. We generally look to the text to govern our analysis
rather than insouciantly follow stray, “incomplete” statements in our prior opinions, see Thryv, Inc. v. Click-To-Call
Technologies, LP, 590 U. S. ___, ___ (2020) (slip op., at 13).
In my view, we should be guided by the text here.
2
Even accepting the Court’s broad interpretation of Clause
2 of Article II, §1, I cannot agree with its determination that
this Clause expressly authorizes the Washington law at issue here. In an attempt to tie Washington’s law to the
State’s “power to appoint an elector,” see ante, at 9, the
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents