6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
Furthermore, upon comprehensive consideration of the following
circumstances, I consider that the Provisions on the Apportionment of
Seats indicate the existence of extreme inequality to such an extent
that it could raise a question of unconstitutionality.
(1) Certainly, each prefecture can be defined as a political unit, and
the 2012 Grand Bench Judgment and the 2014 Grand Bench
Judgment held that it should not be construed that the use of a
prefecture as a unit of constituency is completely not allowed.
However, when the number of prefectures and the population in each
prefecture are compared to the number of members to be elected in
an election, it is obvious that it has become almost impossible to
pursue equality in the value of votes at a ratio close to 1:1 while
adopting the mechanism of apportioning an even number of seats to
each constituency for election for members of the House of
Councillors to be elected by constituency in accordance with the
requirement of the Constitution to hold elections for half elected
members of each constituency, and maintaining the system of
continuously using a prefecture as a unit of constituency in general,
as in the case of the Provisions on the Apportionment of Seats. It is
construed that the Diet recognized these facts and therefore
established the supplementary provision in the 2012 Revision Act,
which stated that review will be made continuously, working toward a
conclusion on the fundamental reform of the election system in
preparation for an ordinary election scheduled in 2016.
(2) On the other hand, a series of Grand Bench Judgments have
pointed out that equality in the value of votes should be realized in
harmony with other policy purposes and grounds that the Diet is
authorized to consider. Therefore, when the Diet cannot realize
equality in the value of votes of voters, which is guaranteed under the
Constitution, in revising an election system or the provisions on the
apportionment of seats, policy purposes and grounds that lead to
such a conclusion are required to be those that the Diet is authorized
to consider and that are in harmony with the requirement of equality
in the value of votes.
For these reasons, with regard to the fact that the Provisions on the
Apportionment of Seats are creating disparity in the value of votes at
around 1:3, I would like to examine what kind of policy purposes and
grounds existed and whether equality in the value of votes is realized
in harmony with other policy purposes and grounds that the Diet is
authorized to consider.
(3) The Diet has not represented any policy purpose of or grounds for
the maximum disparity in the value of votes being 1:3 in the Election
held under the Provisions on the Apportionment of Seats. From the
following facts, however, it can be seen that the policy purpose or the
grounds that the Diet had were to maintain prefecture-based
constituencies and minimize impairment of this basis: the fact that a
prefecture has been used as a unit of constituency throughout the
period from when part of members of the House of Councillors were
elected locally in the past to when part of members of the House of
Councillors were elected by constituency in the previous election; the
fact that the maximum disparity in the value of votes became around
1:3 because the merger in preparation for the Election was conducted
only for four prefectures, each of which has a small population and
was suitable for a merger with its adjacent prefecture also having a
small population, and such merger could not be conducted for some
prefectures, each of which has such small population per member as
the four prefectures but has no less-populated adjacent prefecture
that is suitable for a merger; and the fact that, even though several
proposals were submitted to the Election System Consultation
Meeting that did not stick to the use of a prefecture as a unit of
constituency, making the maximum disparity in the value of votes into
slightly more than 1:1 but not more than 1:2, the Diet had not adopted
th
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
l
til th ti
f th El
ti
17/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents