6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
Councillors, and during the period when this phenomenon continued,
despite the constitutionally guaranteed superiority for the House of
Representatives over the House of Councillors, in reality, the House of
Councillors virtually held the key in national politics. Through such
experience, the significance of the House of Councillors in national
politics has been recognized anew. This being true, as in the case of
the House of Representatives, the election system that provides the
basis for the House of Councillors should also be designed as one
befitted to a representative democracy, causing no disparity in the
value of one vote.
4. Transitional measures in the case when an election is invalidated
(1) The doctrine of judgment in consideration of circumstances for
the public interest has no expressed legal grounds
As mentioned earlier, I consider that the value of one vote must be 1.0
in principle, and a disparity at a level of about 20 percent may be
inevitable, but if any higher disparity emerges, the election should be
invalidated. In that case, there are two major issues to reflect on: [i]
the effect of any decision, etc. made by the House of Representatives
or the House of Councillors whose members are elected in an
election that is invalidated by a court judgment; and [ii] the status of
Diet members elected in an election that is invalidated by a court
judgment.
There is a theory for handling these issues in accordance with the
doctrine of judgment in consideration of circumstances for the public
interest: "even when an election is held to be illegal due to the fact
that it was held under the unconstitutional provisions on the
demarcation of constituencies and apportionment of seats under the
Public Offices Election Act, if there are such circumstances indicated
in the judgment due to which the unconstitutional state would not be
immediately corrected by rendering a judgment to invalidate the
election on the grounds of its illegality, but rather the invalidation of
the election could lead to a consequence that is not necessarily in
conformity to what is expected by the Constitution, the court should,
in accordance with the general rule of law contained in the basis of
Article 31, paragraph (1) of the Administrative Case Litigation Act,
dismiss claims seeking a judgment to invalidate the election, and
declare the illegality of the election in the main text of the judgment"
(the summary of 1974 (Gyo-Tsu) No. 75, judgment of the Grand
Bench of the Supreme Court of April 14, 1976, Minshu Vol. 30, No. 3,
at 223). However, in a suit challenging the constitutionality of a
national election, which is the most important system that supports
representative democracy, I very much doubt if the court, while
finding the election to be illegal, would be permitted to refrain from
invalidating it and only declare its illegality, without any legal grounds
to do so. In fact, looking back at the developments to date, even after
the several legal revisions and discussions at the Diet concerning the
demarcation of constituencies and apportionment of seats, equality in
the value of one vote, which is the core principle of a representative
democracy, has not been completely accomplished, and the process
for improving such a situation has made little progress. In view of this,
the court, as the organ with a mission to ensure the constitutionality
of an election system, must invalidate an election if it clearly finds it
to be unconstitutional, and I consider that the court, at the same time,
has the authority to transitionally decide how to deal with issues that
may arise from invalidating the election.
(2) The effect of any decisions, etc. that have already been made
For example, as for the first of the two issues mentioned above, i.e.
the "effect of any decision, etc. made by the House of
Representatives or the House of Councillors whose members are
elected in an election that is invalidated by a court judgment," since a
court judgment to invalidate an election only has a prospective effect
and is not effective retrospectively, it goes without saying that there is
no room for such judgment to have any influence on a decision, etc.
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
21/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents