6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
made by the Diet before the judgment is rendered, and such decision,
as a matter of course, continues to be effective.
In addition, even after a court judgment to invalidate an election is
rendered, including the period until a new election system designed
to accomplish equality in the value of one vote is established in
response to said judgment and the House of Councillors or the House
of Representatives is formed with members elected in an election
held under the new election system, each House composed of a
certain number of members who continue to hold office will be able to
make an effective decision, etc., as explained later. In this respect,
there is no possibility of turmoil in national politics. Furthermore, even
in such a case where, immediately after a judgment to invalidate an
election is rendered, the House, composed of the same members as
those who held office before said judgment, makes any decision, etc.,
such decision, etc. should be treated as effective in order to avoid
turmoil in national politics.
(3) The status of Diet members elected in an election that is
invalidated
As for the second of the two issues mentioned above, i.e. the "status
of Diet members elected in an election that is invalidated by a court
judgment," in the case of the House of Councillors, if the legality of
the election is challenged in a suit with respect to all constituencies,
as is the present suit, it should be construed that all of the members
who were elected from the constituencies in which the election was
invalidated due to the value of one vote (represented by the number
calculated by dividing the number of eligible voters per member in
each constituency by the national average of eligible voters obtained
by dividing the total number of eligible voters in all constituencies by
the total number of seats apportioned thereto; the same applies
hereinafter) falling below 0.8 would lose their status as members of
the House. This is because it may be impermissible in the first place
to enable members elected from constituencies where the value of
one vote is smaller than the permissible level of 0.8 to maintain their
status and join business at the plenary sessions or committees of the
Diet together with members elected from other constituencies. As for
members elected from other constituencies, the invalidation of the
election does not affect their status as members and they may
continue to be members of the House of Councillors until the
expiration of their term of office. Since an election takes place for half
the members of the House of Councillors every three years (Article 46
of the Constitution), this approach will make it possible for the House
of Councillors to continue its activities and also to hold an emergency
session when necessary.
(Note 1) According to the estimate based on the electoral register
(including overseas voters) as of September 2, 2016, among the 146
members of the House of Councillors to be elected by constituency,
some 38 members would be elected from the constituencies where
the value of one vote falls below 0.8 (if this discussion is limited to
the estimate regarding the ordinary election held on July 10, 2016 for
members of the House of Councillors to be elected by constituency,
among the 73 members of the House of Councillors to be elected by
constituency, some 19 members were elected from the constituencies
where the value of one vote fell below 0.8), and even if these
members lose their status and leave the House, it would have no
particular influence on the composition of members of the House.
(Note 2) On the other hand, in the case of the House of
Representatives, if the court renders a judgment to invalidate an
election, among the members elected from the constituencies subject
to the suit, all the members elected from the constituencies where
the value of one vote falls below 0.8 would lose their status, whereas
the members elected from other constituencies would maintain their
status as members and may continue to be members of the House of
Representatives until the expiration of their term of office or the
dissolution of the House, despite the invalidation of the election.
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
22/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents