6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
According to this approach, the House of Representatives would
transitionally be composed of members elected from the
constituencies where the value of one vote is 0.8 or larger, combined
with members elected from the constituencies excluded from the
scope of the suit if any constituencies are thus excluded. The House
composed of these members would be required to make a law to
specify a new method for the demarcation of constituencies and
thereby accomplish equality in the value of one vote. If it is
impossible for the House to be comprised of these members, an
emergency session of the House of Councillors should be held at the
request of the Cabinet, as in the case where the House of
Representatives is dissolved (Article 54 of the Constitution), and at
the emergency session, the House of Councillors should make a law
to specify a new method for the demarcation of constituencies, under
which the next election of members of the House of Representatives
should be held.
5. An election system designed to accomplish equality in the value of
one vote
How to demarcate constituencies in order to accomplish equality in
the value of one vote should of course be fully discussed at the Diet
when making a law to specify a new method of demarcation of
constituencies or apportionment of seats. There is concern that it
would be extremely difficult or practically impossible to formulate a
policy for demarcation as long as a prefecture or its subdivided area,
i.e. a municipality or any other administrative district, is used as a
basic unit of the constituency. The biggest obstacle is a prefecture,
and its subdivided area, i.e. a municipality or any other administrative
district, can also be a significant obstacle.
Therefore, these types of jurisdiction or subdivision should no longer
be used as a basic unit of constituency. Rather, constituencies should
be demarcated by further dividing these subdivisions into, for
example, areas set up for each polling station, or conversely, by
treating the whole area of the country as a single constituency or
dividing it into several large blocks and setting the number of seats to
be apportioned. I consider that equality in the value of one vote can
only be accomplished by adopting one of these two methods.
Presiding Judge
Justice TERADA Itsuro
Justice OKABE Kiyoko
Justice ONUKI Yoshinobu
Justice ONIMARU Kaoru
Justice KIUCHI Michiyoshi
Justice YAMAMOTO Tsuneyuki
Justice YAMASAKI Toshimitsu
Justice IKEGAMI Masayuki
Justice OTANI Naoto
Justice KOIKE Hiroshi
Justice KIZAWA Katsuyuki
Justice KANNO Hiroyuki
Justice YAMAGUCHI Atsushi
Justice TOKURA Saburo
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
23/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents