6/25/2020
Details of 2017 (Gyo-Tsu) 47 | Judgments of the Supreme Court
inflexible use of a prefecture as a unit of constituency was a cause for
the prolonged existence of great inequality in the value of votes, and
did not hold that the use of a prefecture to determine the
demarcation of each constituency itself is not allowed, as it is
unreasonable.
Basically, it is hard to find grounds to take the requirement of equality
in the value of votes lightly simply because the election in question is
for members of the House of Councillors, and therefore it is
necessary to take the requirement of equality in the value of votes
sufficiently into consideration so that the will of the people will be
reflected more properly in the composition of the House of
Councillors. However, in light of, among other matters, the purpose of
the Constitution and the roles of the House of Councillors as
mentioned above, equality in the value of votes in the election for
members of the House of Councillors still should be realized in
harmony with the abovementioned purpose of the Constitution
pertaining to the bicameral system, taking into account the fact that
the Constitution stipulates that an election for half the members of
the House of Councillors shall take place every three years and other
unique factors that are required to be considered in apportioning
seats for Diet members.
(4) The Election was held under the Provisions on the Apportionment
of Seats as revised by the 2015 Revision Act, which was enacted after
the 2014 Grand Bench Judgment was rendered. Unlike previous
revisions, the 2015 Revision Act not only reapportioned seats among
some constituencies, but also reformed the mechanism of the
election system designed to use a prefecture as a unit of constituency
by merging less-populated constituencies, which was a measure
taken for the first time since the establishment of the House of
Councillors. By virtue of this revision, the maximum disparity between
constituencies, which had remained around the level of 1:5 for dozens
of years until at the time of the 2013 Election, was reduced to 1:2.97
(1:3.08 at the time of the Election).
This revision introduced an unprecedented method that merges some
less-populated constituencies to reform the aforementioned
mechanism, which was the cause for the prolonged existence of great
disparity in the value of votes over a long period of time, and by virtue
of this revision, the maximum disparity between constituencies was
reduced to the abovementioned level. In view of this, it can be seen
that, in light of the abovementioned characteristics of the election of
members of the House of Councillors, this revision endeavored to
correct the disparity in line with the 2012 Grand Bench Judgment and
the 2014 Grand Bench Judgment. In addition, the 2015 Revision Act
states in its supplementary provision that review will be made
continuously, definitely working toward a conclusion on the
fundamental reform of the election system in preparation for the next
ordinary election. We can conclude that the direction and the strong
will of the legislative branch toward further correction of the disparity
in the value of votes in the future are shown in this provision, and that
the legislative branch is endeavoring not to create great disparity at
the abovementioned level again.
Consequently, it can be determined that the 2015 Revision overcame
the prolonged existence of great disparity between constituencies in
terms of the value of votes over a long period of time by reforming the
mechanism of the election system designed to use a prefecture as a
unit of constituency, and is aiming to realize further correction of the
disparity. The fact that only some constituencies were merged and
that many constituencies still use a prefecture as a unit does not
affect this determination.
(5) Upon comprehensive consideration of the above situations, at the
time of the Election, the disparity between constituencies in terms of
the value of votes under the Provisions on the Apportionment of Seats
as revised by the 2015 Revision did not indicate the existence of
extreme inequality to such an extent that it could raise a question of
https://www.courts.go.jp/app/hanrei_en/detail?id=1534
9/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents