Page: 65
determine whether the election results in any specific riding were affected. While the informants
swear that they believe that a person or persons unknown did wilfully prevent or endeavour to
offence has been committed, not to determine whether the commission of the offence changed
the outcome in any riding. And, in most of the interviews conducted, complainants told the
investigators that they had either voted earlier or disregarded the calls and voted at their usual
polling stations relying on the information on their voter cards.
[178] There is some evidence in the ITOs that individual electors were discouraged from
voting. The clearest example is in Guelph where poll staff reported that voters tore up their
identification cards when told that they had been misdirected to the wrong location. A
complainant in the Rivière-du-Nord district stated that he had not exercised his right to vote
because of a misdirecting phone call. However, while complainants were interviewed in four of
the six ridings that are the subject of these proceedings (Winnipeg South Centre, Vancouver
Island North, Nipissing, Yukon), none of them indicated that they had failed to vote as a result of
the calls.
(3)
Mr. Penner’s evidence
[179] In an effort to explain how political parties organize and use telephone calls to potential
electors, the applicants tendered the opinion evidence of Robert Penner, President and Chief
Executive Officer of Strategic Communications Inc. Mr. Penner described himself as a political
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
prevent an elector from voting, the purpose of the ITOs is to obtain evidence to establish that an
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents