Page: 66
consultant with 20 years of experience in developing and implementing voter contact programs
[180] The respondent MPs objected to Mr. Penner's evidence as unfounded and inadmissible
lay opinion. I am satisfied that in the context of these proceedings, Mr. Penner qualifies as an
expert and that his evidence meets the standard for the admission of opinion evidence. The
evidence is helpful with respect to matters with which the Court has no experience.
[181] Mr. Penner explained how telephone calls were used to identify supporters and to ensure
that they got to the polls. In this regard, his evidence was similar to that of Mr. Andrew
Langhorne, the Chief Operating Officer of Responsive Marketing Group Inc., ("RMG") who
gave evidence for the respondent MPs. Both described the process of voter identification (Voter
ID) during the campaign and the "Get-Out-The-Vote" (GOTV) calls on election day.
[182] Mr. Penner observed that the use of harassing and misleading phone calls involving
misinformation about voter registration requirements or polling locations had become
increasingly common in the United States, which had a long history of such tactics. To his
knowledge, however, voter suppression and harassment had not been reported to be features of
Canadian political campaigns until the 2011 election.
[183] In his opinion, a live or recorded call advising an elector that Elections Canada has made
a last-minute change to the elector's polling station location is almost certain to have been
intended to suppress the vote of that elector if the call was made to a supporter of another party.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
and other tools for federal provincial and municipal election campaigns.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents