Page: 70
[192] Apart from the calls made by Ms. Desgagné, RMG did not produce records of the calls
that they made into the subject ridings, as requested by the applicants, on the ground that this
were made by live callers, according to Mr. Langhorne. The data for Voter ID calls was provided
by the CPC and returned to the CPC following the election with the additional inputs regarding
supporters and non-supporters recorded by the callers.
[193] In her supplementary affidavit, Ms. Desgagné deposed that she believed that the text Mr.
Langhorne provided was an amalgam of at least two other scripts she was directed to use, one of
which referred to last minute changes of voting locations by Elections Canada. She believed that
she was directed to use both types of script at various times during the days leading up to the
May 2011 election. According to Langhorne, there would have been no overlap between the
Voter ID and GOTV scripts except possibly on April 29, 2011.
[194] At the hearing, counsel for the applicants advised the Court that they were not relying
upon Ms. Desgagné’s affidavits as evidence of the source of the misleading calls. The respondent
MPs vigorously contested the accuracy of her evidence but relied upon it to the limited extent
that it was inconsistent with the evidence of the applicants and their supporting affiants regarding
the calls that they had received.
[195] Ms. Desgagné’s evidence is based solely upon her recollection which, as she
acknowledged in an interview conducted on CBC radio on February 28, 2012, was unclear. Mr.
2013 FC 525 (CanLII)
would be unduly burdensome. This was not pursued by the applicants. All of the RMG calls
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents