Another progressive case is from Uganda, the
recent Kalali Steven case,30 where the applicant
successfully sought an order declaring that
prisoners aged 18 years and above have the
fundamental and inalienable right to be registered
as voters and to vote pursuant to the Constitution.
The High Court agreed that the exclusion of these
Ugandans from the voters’ registration exercise was
illegal and a violation of their fundamental right to
be registered as voters and participate in various
voting exercises. The Court quoted Sachs J in the
August case (see above) in which he relied on Cory
J of the Canadian Supreme Court, to state that
the right to vote is “so fundamental that a broad
and liberal interpretation must be given to it. Every
reasonable effort should be made to enfranchise
citizens. Conversely every care should be taken to
guard against disenfranchisement.”
make adequate and reasonable arrangements
for all voters registered on the common roll
who would not be in their constituencies on the
polling days which he alleges is unconstitutional.
Providing for as many people to vote as
possible is highly commendable. Failure to
provide in the manner alleged is, however,
not unconstitutional. The contention that the
failure to provide the above facility amounts
to the disenfranchisement of a voter is simply
untenable. The voter does not lose his right to
vote. He is disabled from exercising the right by
being in a wrong constituency at the time he is
expected to vote. The disability would not, in the
circumstances, have resulted from any action
by the Registrar-General.’ The Constitution does
not confer on a voter registered on the common
roll the constitutional right to vote outside the
constituency in which he is registered.
THE DIASPORA COMMUNITY
Another group that is often disenfranchised is
persons in the diaspora. To take the Zimbabwean
example, it is estimated that more than four
million Zimbabweans reside outside the country,
contributing about $1.1 billion per year in foreign
currency remittances. Despite the government
celebrating this economic contribution,31 these four
million people have remained disenfranchised. The
Supreme Court was asked to adjudicate on the
matter in the case of Registrar General of Elections
and Others v Tsvangirai.32 Several issues were put
on the table. First was whether or not the Registrar
General of Elections is obliged to make certain
administrative arrangements to enable voters away
from the constituencies in which they are registered
to vote in other constituencies. On that issue, the
court said:
It is common cause that the first appellant, in
his capacity as Registrar-General of Elections
has directed that each voter on the common
roll shall vote in his or her constituency in
the forthcoming Presidential election. The
respondent is not, in any way, challenging this
decision. It is the failure of the first appellant to
29
30
31
32
56
Second, the court was asked whether a citizen
loses his or her right to vote upon loss of citizenship
by operation of law, even if the person is legally a
permanent resident. In other words, the issue was
whether registered voters who ceased to qualify
to be on the voter’s roll by virtue of having lost or
renounced their citizenship (following the ban on
dual citizenship by law) remained eligible to vote on
the ground that they are permanent residents. On
that issue, the court interpreted the Constitutional
provisions narrowly to hold that a person who was
a citizen as of 31 December 1985 loses his or her
right to vote on ceasing to be a citizen, and that
being a permanent resident does not alter that. The
category of permanent residents as of 31 December
1985 is interpreted narrowly to mean those who
had not yet obtained citizenship but were eligible to
do so, but not those who had lost their citizenship.
The loss of vote or disenfranchisement upon
cessation of citizenship is a loss by operation of
law. In such cases, the constituency registrar, or
anybody else for that matter, cannot reverse such a
loss nor does he have any discretion in the matter.
The law has taken its course, the voter has lost his
or her right to vote by operation of the law and the
loss cannot be revived in any way.
August and Another vs Electoral Commission and Others 1999 (3) SA 1 (CC).
Kalali Steven v Electoral Commission and Attorney General Misc. Cause No. 35 of 2018, Judgment June 2020, para 2.
The Herald, 16 March 2018, ‘Diaspora remittances can spur economy’.
Registrar General of Elections and Others v Tsvangirai, SC 12/2002.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents