Third, the Court was asked whether it is possible to
register for the presidential election on the basis of
citizenship without needing to prove residency in a
particular constituency. The Court held this would
not be possible, and that residence in a particular
constituency must be proved.
Most recently, the Zimbabwean courts were again
asked to address the question of the diaspora
vote in the case of Gabriel Shumba & Others vs
Minister of Justice & Others.33 In this case, the
applicants approached the court challenging the
exclusion of the diaspora vote. The Constitutional
Court held that the law does not confer rights to a
diaspora vote in general. The Constitution, it held,
gives the right to vote to every Zimbabwean citizen
of 18 years of age or over, but that right alone
is not enough. It merely qualifies the citizen for
registration as a voter, but the registration must be
effected on a voter’s roll, and that voters’ roll must
relate or “belong” to a given constituency. Thus,
the Zimbabwean electoral system is constituencybased. The Constitution does not mandate the
setting up of constituencies outside the borders of
Zimbabwe, nor is there any legislative framework
for diaspora voting. Those on government service
overseas and their spouses are an exception; they
are permitted to vote because of the nature of their
job which has forced them out of the country.
The Constitutional Court noted that Gabriel Shumba
had taken this issue to the African Commission
on Human and Peoples’ Rights in 2012. The
Commission had ordered Zimbabwe to allow its
citizens living abroad to be able to vote, based on
the rights set out in the African Charter on Human
and Peoples’ Rights. However, the Constitutional
Court held that it was not bound by that decision,
because the African Charter has not been
specifically incorporated into Zimbabwean law and
therefore is not binding, according to s. 327(2) of
the Constitution.
In South Africa, the courts have taken a different
approach. The case in point is Richter v The
Minister for Home Affairs and Others (with the
33
Democratic Alliance and Others Intervening, and
with Afriforum and Another as Amici Curiae).34 In
this case, the South African Constitutional Court
dealt with the question whether or not South
Africans living abroad had the right to vote. Mr.
Richter was a South African citizen, a registered
voter, who was teaching in the United Kingdom
but who intended to return to South Africa
sometime after the upcoming election. The
Applicant wanted to vote in the election whilst in
the United Kingdom, without returning to South
Africa. He could not do so, as the South African
Electoral Act limited the right to a special vote (i.e.,
a postal vote) to people who were temporarily
outside the country for a holiday, or for a business
trip, or to participate in a sporting event. The
Applicant argued that the restriction violated his
right to vote under Section 19(2) and (3) of the
South African Constitution.
The Constitutional Court upheld Mr. Richter’s
argument on the following grounds:
• The right to vote imposes an obligation on the
•
•
•
•
State to take positive steps to ensure that it can
be exercised.
A citizen must be prepared to take reasonable
steps to exercise the right to vote. For instance,
he or she must be prepared to travel to a polling
station and stand in a long queue. However, the
burden imposed on voters must be reasonable
and must not prevent a voter who is prepared to
take those reasonable steps from exercising his
or her vote.
If a statutory provision prevents a voter from
voting despite the voter’s taking reasonable
steps to do so, the provision infringes the right to
vote enshrined in Section 19 of the South African
Constitution and imposes a restriction that is not
reasonably justifiable in a democratic society.
To require registered voters who are living outside
the country to return to the country to vote imposes
an unreasonable obligation on them.
Hence the restrictions on the right to a special
or postal vote contained in the South African
Electoral Act were unconstitutional.
Gabriel Shumba & Others v Minister of Justice & Others, CCZ 4/18.
57
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents