2019 Presidential Election: Post-Election Report
the practice of holding preliminary meetings behind closed doors to discuss draft CEC Resolutions;
thereby reducing real discussions at the public sessions. Most decisions of the CEC were adopted
unanimously. As in previous elections, the CEC did not initiate public consultations to discuss key draft
resolutions with election stakeholders. The CEC should consider establishing an expert council to
discuss its key draft resolutions, introduce public consultations, and abstain from holding closeddoor preparatory meetings.
Ukrainian NGO Civil Network OPORA raised concerns about CEC attempts to question the presence of
OPORA and other domestic observers at certain CEC sessions, in violation of the Presidential Election
Law that allows domestic and international observers to be present at CEC meetings without an
invitation or the Commission’s consent. A lack of transparency has had consequences in terms of
public perception. In some cases, the CEC did not effectively react to concerns raised by certain
presidential candidates (for instance Anatoliy Hrytsenko) resulting in wide-scale and completely
unreasonable speculations in the media. These speculations included that the CEC allegedly
attempted to “legitimize vote buying,” was attempting to falsify the election result by ordering the
printing of double the amount of ballot papers needed for the first round, and that the State Register
of Voters was of poor quality.
The CEC website still needs to be
modernized
to
ensure
enhanced
accessibility for all voters, including voters
with disabilities, to ensure that CEC
decisions and voter information, as well as
other data are fully accessible. The CEC de
facto restricted access to information on
campaign finance by rejecting requests by
NGOs for access to data on the campaign
expenses of presidential candidates (the CEC
ruled that such data is covered by banking
secret rules). Much can be done to increase
the transparency of the CEC. Enhancing
transparency of the CEC is crucial for building
public trust and strengthening the credibility
and accountability of the institution.
The CEC Chairperson Tatiana Slipachuk and the Head of Sector of
Websites Functioning Volodymyr Som present a draft version of
Commission’s new website to the IT-experts and media
representatives in December 2018.
As a legacy from the past, the CEC remains a highly centralized institution. While the Law on Central
Election Commission allows the CEC to establish regional branches functioning on a permanent basis,
these have never been established due to lack of budget, organizational and other resources. As in
previous elections, any irregularity at district or even precinct level requires CEC action in Kyiv. Such
centralization can hardly be considered necessary and undermines the collegial nature of the
institution, as each CEC member is in charge of supervising elections in a particular region of Ukraine
and has to intervene personally once irregularities occur in a particular region/district. The Rada
should consider changes to the Law on Central Election Commission to specify the mandates of the
CEC branches in the regions, while the government should allocate resources needed to establish
such branches.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents