IFES Ukraine
District Election Commissions (DECs)
Before the first round of the presidential election, the CEC formed DECs on time and based on
nominations filed by the presidential candidates. While the Presidential Election Law establishes that
the minimum composition of a DEC is 12 members, it does not impose any restrictions on the
maximum members of a DEC. A presidential candidate is entitled to suggest one commissioner for
each DEC subject to approval by the CEC if the proposed nominees comply with the legal requirements
for DEC membership. The Presidential Election Law requires all DECs to be formed anew by the CEC
within a short ten-day deadline before a potential second round based on submissions of the two
presidential candidates running in the second round. Both candidates are entitled to nominate seven
DEC members each, while the DEC is to comprise 14 members overall.
For the first round of the 2019 presidential election, the CEC initially registered 44 presidential
candidates (of which five later withdrew their candidacy), most of whom nominated members to
DECs. Due to the large number of nominees proposed, DECs on average included 37 members. The
smallest DEC was No 105 in Luhansk oblast with 29 members, while the largest DECs included 41
members (DECs Nos 174 and 176 in Kharkiv oblast).
Large membership does not contribute to the effective performance of DECs and unnecessarily
complicates election administration operations as most election-related documents must be signed
by all the DEC members. Large DECs also result in overcrowding of their premises, a fact noted by
most election observer groups as negatively affecting DEC operations and transparency during the
tabulation of votes, since all DEC sessions can further be attended by observers, presidential
candidates and their proxies, journalists, and members of the CEC. The Presidential Election Law,
therefore, should be reviewed to establish the maximum composition of the DECs to make sure
they could effectively manage the election process.
Before the second round, all DECs were created anew by the CEC and both presidential candidates,
nominated candidates to most DECs as foreseen by the Presidential Election Law. Petro Poroshenko
nominated seven members to all DECs, while Volodymyr Zelenskyi did not suggest any nominees in
two election districts (Nos 57 and 58 in Mariupol). The vacant seats on these DECs were filled by the
CEC based on the proposal of the CEC Chair, as envisaged by law. OPORA noted that the overall process
of the DEC re-establishment before the second round was much better compared to the first round,
and both presidential candidates received a balanced representation on the DECs, including DEC
executive positions.
The approach towards establishment of the DECs laid down in the Presidential Election Law is
problematic in a number of aspects. Complete re-establishment of DECs for the second round might
have a negative impact on the level of professionalism of DEC commissioners, as the narrow
timeframes between the rounds do not allow for sufficient time to properly train new DEC members.
Further, if candidates decide not to propose any nominees to certain DECs, it might be difficult for the
CEC to identify enough prospective commissioners and bring into question the principle of equal
representation on the commission. Furthermore, the formation of DECs and, subsequently, PECs may
then suffer from significant delays that would negatively impact preparations for the second round.
For these reasons, the provision in the Presidential Election Law requiring complete re-appointment
of election commissioners shortly before a potential second round should be reconsidered.
8
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents