2019 Presidential Election: Post-Election Report
Civil society and media lacked day-to-day access to information about candidates’ incomes and
expenditures, as the CEC has ruled that this information falls under the bank secrecy clause. The public
has access to this information, but only after the reports are published, i.e. shortly before election day
(which leaves no time for the public to analyze the published information) or after the election (when
the analysis has a limited effect). Consequently, voters do not have the opportunity to make a fully
informed choice when they go to the polls. The election laws, including the Presidential Election Law,
should be amended to state that all information contained in the financial reports/election fund
bank accounts that are subject to publication by the CEC and NAPC can be provided to any
stakeholder upon request prior to the official publication, and that such information should not be
covered by the bank secrecy clause.
Current sanctions for failure to comply with the campaign finance requirements can hardly be
considered proportionate, effective, or dissuasive, as most campaign finance violations are only
subject to the issuance of a warning to the candidate in question or to an administrative fine ranging
from UAH 5,100 – 6,800 (equivalent of USD 192-256). Furthermore, sanctions are difficult to impose
due to short statutes of limitations (after this period expires, the court cannot consider the case). The
Criminal Code and Code of Administrative Offences should be changed to introduce effective,
proportionate and dissuasive sanctions for political/campaign finance violations.
Election dispute resolution
Depending on its type, a complaint/lawsuit may be filed with the CEC, a DEC or a PEC, or to a local
court of general jurisdiction, a District Administrative Court, the respective administrative court of
appeals or the Supreme Court. Most types of disputes can be filed with an election commission and/or
with a court at the discretion of the complainant. Although such overlapping jurisdictions are foreseen
in Constitution, which entitles anyone to challenge any irregularity at a court directly, it has in practice
not caused any significant problems in recent elections. There have been no cases when the same
complaint on the same subject matter has been heard in parallel by a court and an election
commission. Despite this, overlapping jurisdictions have been repeatedly criticized by the Venice
Commission and ODIHR, who jointly recommended to remove it from the legal framework. While
introducing amendments to the Constitution of Ukraine, the Rada should consider changes aimed
to eliminate the possibility of parallel consideration of the same complaint by the courts and
administrative/executive bodies such as election commissions.
A complaint to an election commission must be filed within five days of the violation (with a few
exceptions depending on the type of the case). Lawsuits regarding violations committed before
election day must be filed within five days of the violation (except for lawsuits against inaccuracies on
the voter lists), while lawsuits against violations committed on election day and afterward must be
filed within two days of the violation. In almost all cases, the CEC, DEC, PEC or court are required to
provide a decision within two days of receiving the complaint. The Code of Administrative
Adjudication provides that all court decisions can be challenged to the respective next instance court
(i.e., to an administrative court of appeals or the Supreme Court/Grand Chamber of the Supreme
Court, depending on the court that considered the case in the first instance). An appeal must usually
be filed within two days following the day when the first court decision was announced.
19
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents