IFES Ukraine
While the IEOM noted that courts adhered to the two-day deadline for resolving disputes, such a
narrow deadline may cause difficulties if the allegation is complex and/or requires investigation. On
the other hand, the five-day deadline for filing complaints can potentially derail the election process
in the second round, as the CEC cannot proceed with second round preparations until all election
disputed have been resolved by the courts. In some cases, resolution of disputes related to the first
round outcome may take up to 8-11 days or even more, while the CEC is required to establish the first
and second round results within ten days following the election. Any delay with establishing the first
round results caused by election disputes pending in courts may delay the formation of DECs and PECs
and thus render it practically impossible to hold the second round vote within three weeks of the first
round vote, as required by law. The timelines for filing election-related complaints and resolving
election disputes should be reviewed to allow courts sufficient time to resolve complex cases
without derailing preparations for second round.
A complaint/lawsuit must comply with detailed requirements set forth in the Presidential Election Law
(if filed to an election commission) or the Code of Administrative Adjudication (if filed to court). The
list of mandatory requirements includes full contact details of all the parties to a case, the substance
of the violation, motivation, and evidence, precisely formulated claims and description of the decision
to be adopted in the case, among other things. Failure to comply with any of these requirements may
result in the lawsuit/complaint being sent back to the complainant for correction without being
considered on its merits. The CEC received more than 130 complaints in the first round and 43 in the
second round, most of which were rejected by private letter from an individual CEC commissioner
(rather than by the entire commission) for technical reasons (i.e. failure to meet the formal
requirements to a complaint). Most second round complaints were rejected by the CEC for this reason.
The practice of rejecting complaints on technical grounds has been criticized by ODIHR for years as it
denies the complainant an effective remedy against administrative action, contrary to OSCE
commitments. The Presidential Election Law should provide that if a complaint fails to comply with
technical requirements but contains the necessary data to allow the violation to be identified and
verified/investigated, such a complaint must be further investigated by the relevant election
commission.
IFES conducted comprehensive training
exercises for judges of all administrative
courts (both district and administrative
courts of appeals) before the first round of
the election. Despite the fact that the
judiciary overall managed to resolve cases
related to the presidential election in line
with legal requirements and international
standards, the IEOM noted that some court
judgments lacked a sound legal basis,
thereby limiting the access to an effective
Judges of administrative courts take part in an interactive training
remedy for violations of electoral rights and
for trainers (TOT) jointly organized by IFES and the National School
casting doubts about the independence of of Judges on January 30, 2019.
the judiciary. According to the IEOM, the
cases concerned included several unsuccessful cases against the incumbent over alleged misuse of
official position and state resources, and one case against Zelenskyi for allegedly bypassing campaign
20
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents