interpretation came when she considered the late opening of the polls and the
effect of this under Rule 1(7). I would therefore now consider the question
whether the judge erred when she held that the late opening of the polls breached
Rule 1(7) and therein review her interpretation of this Rule, and, later, consider
whether the judge erred when she held that late voting by persons who were in the
lines at 6:00pm did not breach Rule 1(7)..
Did the late opening of the polls breach Rule 1(7)?
[75]
Section 32(1) of the Representation of the People Act (as amended) provides
that the proceedings at an election shall be conducted in accordance with the
election rules contained in the First Schedule to the said Act. The First Schedule
to the original Act was repealed by the 2002 amending Act, which substituted the
present Election Rules. Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules expressly provides as
follows:
“(1) The proceedings at the election shall be conducted in accordance
with the following provisions:
…
(7) In the case of a general election or a by-election, polling shall
take place between the hours of 6 a.m. and 6 p.m. on the day
specified in the writ by the Governor-General.”
[76]
It is common ground that the polls opened late in the contested constituencies.
There was uncontroverted evidence of the late opening of the polls, particularly
from the returning officers for those constituencies. The trial judge accepted their
evidence. There were witnesses on behalf of each petitioner who testified that
they were unable to vote because the polls opened late in those constituencies.44
[77]
It is common ground that, in the St. George constituency, the New Winthorpes
polling station opened at 8:50am; the Piggotts polling station opened at 8.30am,
and the Potters polling station opened at 11;20am. In the St. John’s Rural North
constituency, the polling station at York’s opened at 8:00am; the polling station at
44
See paragraphs 205, 206, 207 and 208 of the judgment.
35
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents