Wesleyan opened at 8:35am and the polling station at Cedar Grove opened at
8:00am. In the St. John’s Rural West constituency, the polling station at Miss
Generlette Building opened at 8:30am; the polling station at St Anthony’s Church
opened at 7:55am; the polling station at Nazarene Church opened at 7:45am; the
polling station at Exhibition and Cultural (Multicultural) Centre opened at 7:30am;
the polling station at Greenbay Primary School opened at 12:45pm and the polling
station at Five Islands School opened at 10:10am.
[78]
The judge’s decision that the late opening of the polls in the St. George
constituency breached Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules fairly reflects her
reasoning on this finding in the other 2 contested constituencies. She stated:45
“[228] The Court now considers the first issue, namely, whether there
was a breach of the election law. In seeking to make this determination,
the Court takes into consideration the findings of fact and applies the
principles of law thereto. The Court has no doubt, based on its finding,
that there was a clear breach of the election law when the polling station
did not open at 6 a.m. for polling. Parliament intended that polling should
start at 6 a.m. This did not occur, in relation to each of the polling stations
in St. George. Prima facie, once the polling does not commence at 6
a.m., there is a breach of the law.”
[79]
The interpretation of Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules was critical to this decision.
The judge’s interpretation of Rule 1(7)
[80]
The judge examined the competing submissions relating to the interpretation of
Rule 1(7).46 She stated47 that it was imperative that the court should give effect to
the intention of the legislature. The judge suggested48 that most of the authorities
to which counsel referred were not helpful because they were not based on rules
that were similar to Rule 1(7). She continued as follows:
“One thing is clear, however: the rule must be given a purposive
At paragraph 228 of the judgment.
See from paragraph 218 of the judgment.
47 At paragraph 219 of the judgment.
48 At paragraph 220 of the judgment.
45
46
36
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents