the polls. The legislature could not have intended Rule 1(7) to sanction these
shortcomings and inconveniences.
[89]
It seems clear to me that the strict interpretation of Rule 1(7), which the trial judge
provided, is the meaning that the legislature intended the Rule to have. Her
interpretation makes good sense and good law and was correct. It follows that the
judge was also correct in finding, by extension, that the late opening of the polls
breached Rule 1(7) of the Election Rules. Accordingly, I would dismiss the
grounds of the appeal by the appellants which challenge this decision.
[90]
I would now consider whether the learned trial judge erred when she held that late
voting by persons who were in the lines by 6.00pm did not breach Rule 1(7) of the
Election Rules.
Late voting and breach of Rule 1(7)
[91]
This issue arises on the counter-notice. I think that a detailed reproduction of the
reasons for the judge’s decision that late voting by persons who were in the lines
at 6:00pm did not breach Rule 1(7) would be helpful at this juncture.
[92]
The judge stated her reasons for decision as follows:
“[224] … the Court is obliged to ascertain the intention of the Legislature.
Here again, the Court holds the view that the section must be given a
purposive interpretation. I am ineluctably driven to conclude that the
Legislature’s intention was that electors who had entered the line before 6
p.m. should, indeed I would say, must be permitted to cast their ballot,
even if they reached the voting clerk after 6 p.m. Having given careful
consideration to the competing arguments, the Court cannot sensibly
accept that the Legislature’s intention was to disenfranchise persons who
were in the lines at 6 p.m. waiting to vote. Furthermore, the Court is
persuaded that to turn away an elector who had joined the line before 6
p.m. simply because he reached the polling booth after 6 p.m. would
infringe the constitutional right to vote as provided for by section 40 of the
Constitution of Antigua and Barbuda. To give the section any other
meaning would lead to absurd and unfair results. Indeed, any such
40
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents