construction could lead to a stampede as the hour approached 6 p.m.
Again, the Court should be slow to attribute such an intention to the
Legislature.”
[93]
The judge continued:53
“[225] To emphasize, should the Court accept the position urged by
Learned Queen’s Counsel, Mr. Guthrie, it would mean electors who are in
line for several hours well before 6 p.m., but who for reasons over which
they had no control are unable to vote by 6 p.m., would be debarred from
voting on the striking of the hour 6 p.m. This would be unjust and could
never have been the legislative intention. …
[226] …
[227] While the rule mandates that polling concludes at 6 p.m., it must be
read in a purposeful manner to mean that persons who are lawfully in line
at 6 p.m. must be permitted to exercise their franchise. See Bruno v The
Election Appeal Board of the Samson supra. Accordingly, on this
aspect of the petition, the Court accepts the arguments advocated by
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Mendes and Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
Martineau in preference to those advanced by Learned Queen’s Counsel,
Mr. Guthrie. The Court therefore holds that it is not a breach of Rule 1(7)
to permit persons who are in line at 6 p.m. to exercise their franchise.”
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
[94]
Mr. Guthrie submitted that, in the first place, even 1 hour’s voting after 6:00pm
may amount to a significant number of votes, which would have had some effect
on the result. Counsel stated that, given the evidence that it takes an average of 1
or 2 minutes for a voter to cast his or her vote, the number voting after 6.00pm in
the constituency would have added more than 100 voters. This, he said, would
have had a distorting effect on the final numbers.
[95]
In the second place, Mr. Guthrie pointed to the press release, which the
Supervisor of Elections, Lorna Simon, caused to be issued on election day
encouraging people to vote. The release stated: “The law does not allow for voting
time to be extended beyond the 6 pm deadline.” Mr. Guthrie submitted that this
statement was correct as a matter of law. He argued, however, that it was
53
At paragraph 225 and 227 of the judgment.
41
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents