[98] Mr. Mendes submitted that on a proper interpretation of Rule 1(7), persons in line at the polling station at 6:00pm should be permitted to vote. He insisted that any interpretation which disenfranchises such persons would violate the constitutional right to vote. Alternatively, Mr. Mendes submitted that an interpretation which precludes persons in line at 6:00pm from voting after 6:00pm is unconstitutional because it would be an unlawful constraint on the person’s constitutional right to vote. Counsel invited the court either to declare Rule 1(7) void, in that it infringes section 40(3) of the Constitution if the Rule does permit a person who is in the line at 6:00pm to vote thereafter. Alternatively, he invites us to modify Rule 1(7) to bring it into conformity with section 40. He referred to Gribbin v Kirker;54 The West Division of the Borough of Islington,55 Halstead v Simon, Darrel Regan Bruno and Another v The Election Appeal Board of the Samson Cree Nation and Others,56 Randolph Russell v Attorney General of St Vincent and the Grenadines,57 and Sauve v Attorney General of Canada.58 The cases [99] In Gribbin v Kirker, section 64 of “An Act for the Regulation of Municipal Corporations in Ireland” governed the hours of voting in elections.59 It stated, among other things, “ … voting at every such Election shall commence at Nine o’clock in the Forenoon, and shall finally close at Four of the Clock in the Afternoon of the same Day, …” An unidentified number of persons were in line but had not yet voted at 4:00pm. At 4:00pm the outer door of the house where the poll was held was closed. Those within at that time were polled until about 5:00pm. Counsel for the respondent argued that those who were polled after 4:00pm were there to give their votes before 4:00pm., and, consequently, the fault not being theirs, they should not suffer. Counsel for the petitioner argued that the [1873] IR 30. (1901) 5 O’M & H 120. 56 2006 FCA 249. 57 (1995) 50 WIR 127. 58 [2002] 3 SCR 519. 59 1840, 3 & 4 Vic. c. 108. 54 55 43

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents