language of section 64 was clear and mandatory. The court stated as follows:
“The provisions of the statute, requiring the poll to be closed at 4
o’clock, p.m., have not been complied with. The cases quoted
are not applicable, and do not go the length of deciding that the
result of the poll must be shown to have been affected by keeping
the poll open after 4 o’clock, p.m. Mr. Kirker was the senior
Alderman. The election must be set aside. Each party to pay his
own costs.”
[100]
Counsel for the respondents submitted that, in so far as the stipulated period is
concerned, section 64 has the effect to prevent voting after 4:00pm, just as Rule 1
(7) in Antigua and Barbuda is intended to prevent voting after 6:00pm. Counsel
asked us to note that in the judgment, Monahan CJ used the word poll, in place of
the word ‘voting’. Counsel argued that the Chief Justice did this because ‘voting’
and ‘polling’ are synonymous. Respectfully, I do not think that we could draw this
conclusion because there is nothing in the judgment to suggest that the learned
Chief Justice actually addressed his mind to the question whether those words are
synonymous. Additionally, section 64 is clearly mandatory in its requirement that
voting shall end at 4.00pm. Rule 1(7) is not in the same terms.
[101]
In Islington, the winning candidate was elected by a majority of 19 votes. It was
proved that 14 ballot papers were delivered to electors after the closing hour of
8pm. However, those electors were at the polling place by 8:00pm. It was also
proved that some ballots which were received before 8:00pm were cast after that
time. The election court held that the ballots that were cast after 8.00pm were
invalid. The relevant statute was section 1 of the Elections (Hours of Poll) Act
1885. It provided that the poll “shall commence at eight o’clock in the forenoon
and shall be kept open till eight o’clock in the afternoon of the same day and no
longer.” [My emphasis]. ‘Poll’ was defined to mean actual voting.60 In my view,
the words “and no longer” and the definition of ‘poll’ made it pellucid that actual
voting had to cease at 8:00pm. The court was therefore quite correct when it
construed the provision to mean that voters who were in the polling station at
60
See page 121 of the Report.
44
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents