8:00pm could not vote after 8:00pm.
[102]
It is noteworthy, however, that the court found that a voter to whom a ballot was
given before 8:00pm was entitled to vote and to deposit it into the ballot box after
8:00pm. The court observed that the rules required voters who had received a
ballot ‘forthwith’ to take the ballot into one of the compartments and deposit it into
the ballot box. The court stated that since there was no provision as to how such
a ballot was to be dealt with, and it was clearly not a ‘spoiled’ or an ‘unused’ ballot,
it had to be deposited. In any event, inasmuch as the winning candidate prevailed
by 19 votes, and there were only 14 invalid votes, the respondent would still have
won by 5 votes. The court therefore declined to invalidate the election.
[103]
Halstead v Simon came out of an election in Antigua and Barbuda. The time
provided for the polls was contained in the precursor provision to Rule 1(7), which
provided as follows:
“The proceedings at the election shall be conducted in
accordance with the following table …. In the case of a general
election between the hours of 6 a.m. and 6 p.m.”
[104]
Mr. Mendes submitted that it is clear from the report that there was no contention
that the rule should be interpreted as permitting persons in line at 6:00pm to cast
their votes after 6:00pm. The result, he said, was that the court proceeded on the
assumption that the law prohibited voting after 6.00pm. I agree that Halstead
provides little helpful guidance on this issue inasmuch as it was not canvassed
and duly considered. The court focused on the question whether there was
substantial compliance with electoral law and whether the breaches of those laws
affected the result of the election.
[105]
It is however noteworthy that, in the present case, the trial judge relied on the
reasoning in Bruno. In Bruno, the Federal Court of Appeal of Canada held that
persons in line at the closing hour were entitled to stay on to vote. The statute
which provided for the opening and closing of the polls stated: “All voting
45
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents