in a case where there was only 5½ hours of voting time, if everyone on the voters
list had cast their ballots, in those circumstances, without anything more, no Court
despite the breach, would declare the election void. The Court must take a
common sense approach at the situation.
Learned counsel noted that in
Halstead, there was both a loss of regular voting time and an excess of voting
time after the stipulated hour. It would be recalled that in that case the court found
that voting commenced at 6:00am but stopped at about 12:30pm to 1:00pm
because of a shortage of ballot papers. Voting re-commenced at about 5:30pm to
5.40pm and continued until about 9.00pm.86
[141]
Learned counsel noted that the Halstead case showed that there were 2,829
registered voters in the constituency. The winner, Mr. Simon, received 874 votes,
while the petitioner received 611 and a third candidate received 67 votes. The
margin of victory was therefore 263 votes. There were 9 rejected ballots. The
turnout was accordingly 55%.87 Voting time was extended by 3 hours to 9pm by
judicial order. Redhead J found as a fact that there were 850 persons on the
Register who were not physically present in Antigua and Barbuda on elections
day. Accordingly, he found that 76% of the electorate voted who were in the
country. The percentage of the total registered electors who voted would have
been 50% if the 850 who were not physically present were included.88 It was in
these circumstances, said counsel, that Redhead J expressed the view that the
election was not conducted in a way as to make the ordinary man deem it as a
sham or travesty, and, further, he had no doubt that there was a real election by
ballot. He concluded that the election was conducted substantially in accordance
with the law as to elections.89 Counsel said that it is clear that where a substantial
number of voters are disenfranchised, that an election can be said to be a sham or
a travesty. He cited the statement to that effect by the Court of Common Pleas in
See page 203.
See page 201.
88 See pages 228-229.
89 See page 233.
86
87
61
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents