Woodward v Sarsons.90
[142]
Learned counsel urged this court to distinguish Hackney from the present case on
the facts.
[143]
In Hackney, there were three candidates. The winning candidate received 6,968
votes; the runner-up received 6,893 votes and the candidate in third place
received 6,310 votes. Only 75 votes separated the winner from the runner-up. In
their submissions, counsel for the appellants noted that the court found it proved,
in Hackney, that as nearly 5,000 people were unable to vote at the 2 stations that
were closed, and a large number of other people were either prevented or might
reasonably be supposed to have been prevented from voting at the other 3
stations. Grove J stated that one of the principles of the Act was that the electors
should have a fair opportunity of recording their votes. Accordingly, the question to
be decided was:91
“… is it in accordance with the principles of the Act that a large proportion,
amounting to several thousands of the electors, should be absolutely
deprived of the power of voting, and that a large indefinite number, which
we cannot ascertain, should also have impediments presented to their
voting, which may, and doubtless did, prevent a very considerable number
of them from voting at all?”
Grove J expressed the view that the real point in the case was “whether the
constituency had had an opportunity of fairly recording their votes for the different
candidates.”92 He concluded as follows:93
“… I am perfectly certain … that an election which is conducted in
such a way as (whether by accident or by design) not to afford to
a very large mass of the electors an opportunity of voting, cannot
be a true election of members … (I)t appears to me that there was
no real election here which was in any sense a fair representation
of the views of the electors of the Borough of Hackney.”
[1874-75] L.R. 10 C.P. 733, at pages 743-744.
See page 83 of the Report of the judgment.
92 See page 80 of the Report of the judgment.
93 At page 81 of the report of the judgment.
90
91
62
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents